• be_ixf; php_sdk; php_sdk_1.4.11
  • 23 ms
  • iy_2023; im_12; id_04; ih_09; imh_13; i_epoch:1.70170999763E+12
  • ixf-compiler; ixf-compiler_1.0.0.0
  • py_2018; pm_11; pd_14; ph_12; pmh_14; p_epoch:1.54222645072E+12
  • link-block; link-block_link-block; bodystr
  • pn_tstr:Wed Nov 14 12:14:10 PST 2018; pn_epoch:1.54222645072E+12
  • 0 ms
  • be_ixf; php_sdk; php_sdk_1.4.11
  • https://www.naes.com/news/2019-nyc-power-outage/
  • https://www.naes.com/news/2019-nyc-power-outage/
Skip to content
NAES
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Services
    • Power Services
    • Compliance & Fleet Services
      • Engineering
      • E3 Consulting
      • O&M Services
      • Regulatory Compliance Services
      • Maximo Services
      • Field Engineering and Research
    • Fabrication, Maintenance, & Construction
    • Staffing Services
  • About Us
    • Subsidiaries
    • Leadership
  • Communications
    • News
    • Case Studies
    • Press Releases
  • Careers
  • Contact
    • Contact a Location
    • NAES Login Center
New York

In the News

Home Communications In the News 2019 NYC Power Outage

10.15.2019

2019 NYC Power Outage

2019 NYC Power Outage

By Joseph Bennett, Senior NERC Reliability Specialist

On July 13, 2019, approximately 70,000 to 73,000 people lost power in a 30-block area of Midtown Manhattan and Manhattan’s west side. A tourist-filled Times Square and Broadway were shut down by the outage just as shows were set to go on.

The power outage also affected the entire NYC Subway system and the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) had to close four Manhattan stations and advised people to use the bus system due to uncertainty about the subway system due to not knowing the cause of the power outage. The FDNY also had to send responders to assist people who were stuck in elevators in high rise buildings throughout the affected area due to the loss of power. NYPD was dispatched to the affected areas to direct traffic due to the failure of traffic signals.

The outage was initially reported as being possibly due to a manhole explosion which was initially verified. Initially Con Edison stated the cause of the outage was a mechanical failure that it felt could be resolved relatively quickly but was unable to give an estimate on when power would be restored. Upon further investigation, it was determined that cause of the blackout was a transformer fire at one of the substations. While investigating the transformer explosion and fire, the root cause was traced to a relay in the substations transformer protection system that did not operate properly.

In a statement by Con Edison, they stated that in this case, primary and backup relay systems did not isolate a faulted 13,000-volt distribution cable at West 64th Street and West End Avenue. Initially, the fault on the 13kV system and the power outage were not thought to be connected by system operators. During the investigation, it was determined that the events were linked. The fault actually started on the 13kV system which then was exacerbated by the failure of the relay protection system to operate and trip the system off line. This led to an overload on a transformer in the substation which caused the transformer to explode and catch fire. All of this leading power outage that affected a large portion of Manhattan as well as people in surrounding areas due to a major disruption in transportation.

To prevent a similar occurrence in the future, Con Edison isolated all their similar relays in their system and performed testing and maintenance on the relays prior to returning them to service in order to ensure that the failure would not occur again.

In the end, it only took Con Edison 5 hours to restore power to the 70+ thousand affected customers and get the subway back up and running again. It did take several more days and countless hours to investigate similar relay protection systems and ensure that there wouldn’t be a similar problem in the future that would lead to another outage on Con Edison’s system.

Join the Conversation

  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
NAES

© Copyright 2023 NAES. All rights reserved.

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Do Not Sell My Personal Information

Website design by Jordan Crown

  • Services
    • Power Services
    • Compliance & Fleet Services
      • Engineering
      • E3 Consulting
      • O&M Services
      • Regulatory Compliance Services
      • Maximo Services
      • Field Engineering and Research
    • Fabrication, Maintenance, & Construction
    • Staffing Services
  • About Us
    • Subsidiaries
    • Leadership
  • Communications
    • News
    • Case Studies
    • Press Releases
  • Careers
  • Contact
    • Contact a Location
    • NAES Login Center

‹ › ×
    Manage Cookie Consent
    We use cookies to optimize our website and our service.
    Functional cookies Always active
    The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
    Preferences
    The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
    Statistics
    The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
    Marketing
    The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
    Manage options Manage services Manage vendors Read more about these purposes
    View preferences
    {title} {title} {title}
    CAISO Generator Modeling Process and Data Requirements

    Don’t wait until the last minute. You should allow time for at least one iteration with CAISO so that you are complete and deemed compliant before your deadline.

    On August 1, 2018, CAISO introduced a revised Business Practice Manual for Transmission Planning Process (BPM), which includes new data requirements for interconnected generation resources within the ISO’s footprint. Section 10 of the BPM establishes revised data requirements and compliance procedures for all participating generators including non-NERC registered entities. While additional requirements have been placed on larger NERC registered facilities, these changes may pose an even greater burden to entities that have been exempt from NERC mandated modeling and protection requirements.

    New data requirements include voltage and frequency protection models, power flow models, and in some cases, sub-synchronous resonance models. These models must be verified using criteria listed in the BPM, which can only be performed by entities with modeling software and knowledge of modeling practices.

    NAES is prepared to assist entities with data aggregation, modeling, and testing to ensure compliance with CAISO’s data requests. The following links will allow entities to determine when to expect their individual data requests (phase) and what data will be required (category).

    Business Practice Manual (BPM)

    Entity Category and Phase Listing

    CAISO Transmission Planning Website

    TPL-007

    TPL-007 establishes planning criteria for induced currents caused by geomagnetic disturbances. The standard is applicable to facilities using transformer(s) with a high side, wye grounded winding operated above 200 kV and can require both submittal of general geomagnetic data (R2) and thermal impact assessments (R6) depending on results of Planning Coordinator analysis.

    VOLTAGE AND REACTIVE (VAR) STANDARDS

    VAR-501-WECC

    VAR-501-WECC requires applicable entities within the WECC region to confirm performance settings and characteristics of Power System Stabilizers (PSS). NAES provides physical testing and reporting services to address WECC’s specific PSS requirements.

    PERSONNEL PERFORMANCE, TRAINING AND QUALIFICATIONS

    PER-006

    PER-006 requires Generator Operators to provide training to personnel who are responsible for the Real-time control of a generator. NAES has developed specific protection system training materials suitable for compliance with the Standard and provides this training both on and off site

    PROTECTION AND CONTROL (PRC) STANDARDS

    PRC-001

    PRC-001 requires entities to coordinate protection system changes with other affected parties. NAES offers both procedural documentation and engineering services to establish the required coordination for both PRC-001 and PRC-027.

    PRC-002

    PRC-002 requires the installation and operation of disturbance monitoring equipment (DME) for applicable entities. NAES can assist with the design and installation of DME as well as ongoing compliance support.

    PRC-019

    PRC-019 requires applicable entities to show coordination between voltage regulating controls, limiters, equipment capabilities, and protection settings. NAES produces PRC-019 specific coordination studies for both traditional generators and renewable projects to establish compliance with the Standard.

    PRC-023

    PRC-023 requires load responsive protective relays be set according to criteria within the Standard to ensure settings do not limit transmission loadability. NAES provides full engineering analyses to maintain compliance with this Standard.

    PRC-024

    PRC-024 requires applicable entities to ensure generator protective relays do not trip within predefined frequency and voltage limits. NAES can complete protection settings analyses and provide compliance documentation that clearly identifies protection settings as they relate to NERC’s “no trip” zones.

    PRC-025

    PRC-025 establishes minimum settings requirements for load-responsive relays protecting generators, step up transformers, and auxiliary transformers. NAES utilizes predefined calculation options as well as simulations to determine a facility’s compliance status and development of new relay settings if required.

    PRC-026

    PRC-026 requires applicable entities to perform load responsive relay settings analyses based on criteria identified within the Standard. Entities are typically notified by the Planning Coordinator when an analysis is required. NAES performs all required studies to establish compliance.

    MODELING, DATA, AND ANALYSIS (MOD) STANDARDS

    MOD-025

    MOD-025 requires Real and Reactive Power capability testing for individual generating units over 20 MVA or facilities with over 75 MVA of generation capacity. NAES offers site specific test procedures and/or complete onsite testing services to meet the requirements of this standard.

    MOD-026

    MOD-026 requires verification of excitation or volt/var control dynamic models through utilization of either system disturbances or physical testing. NAES offers full testing and modeling services to meet the requirements of this standard.

    MOD-027

    MOD-027 requires verification of governor or active power/frequency control dynamic models through utilization of either system disturbances or physical testing. NAES offers full testing and modeling services to meet the requirements of this standard.